THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Mahwah, NJ - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated April 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“For a first time visit, I thoroughly enjoyed this place! My boyfriend and I went for our 1 year celebration and we enjoyed the food and Milkis! The staff were so kind - honestly, I like how the staff were placing the meats for us on the grill. Overall, we’d definitely come back to Prime No. 7 again!”

Customers` Favorites

“We absolutely love this place!! The food is 5 stars delicious. The owners/waiters are very polite and do the best they can on a busy Friday night. I really enjoy the music and mood lighting and find the table and chairs to be comfortable. Sometimes the food/lassi does not come all at once but we usually share so we don’t mind. Highly recommend if you like indian food”

Customers` Favorites

“Being new to the Mahwah area I have been searching for a go to spot for good coffee and/or tea as well as a good bacon egg and cheese sandwich…. and I have found it ! I love the vibe from Longfellows Coffee! It has a new and modern vibe while giving a nostalgic 90’s feeling, which brings back nice memories for me. The coffee was excellent and the egg sandwich was delicious. The staff was very pleasant to interact with (I don’t know any names yet) and this is a place you can feel at home with. Highly recommend!!”

Customers` Favorites

“We've gone there for Pasta night more than any other time. We love ❤️ Chef Pierre and his pasta night. The only other night we went to eat for regular dinner was OK.”

Customers` Favorites

“I've been coming here for Taco Tuesday for a little bit trying to give it a chance and unfortunately to just too cheap of a meal for you to enjoy. They literally put like no ingredients in that taco. You're basically writing into a tortilla shell there's just nothing inside and it ends up being a really bad meal for the price. I understand it's a discount but they could do a little bit better with the amount of food that they put inside the taco shell It's basically a plastic container with a bunch of lettuce a taco shell and about a half a tablespoon of meat. Employees are so kind and very very nice so I feel bad it feels like they're being told to put such a small amount but if you could do better I would definitely be returning but for now I'm going to give this place a little break.”

Customers` Favorites

“The most amazing food! We bought a tray of Eggplant Parm and Eggplant Rollatini for Christmas Eve. Both absolutely delicious. . My picky Italian relatives loved them. We have also had the Chicken Madeira with broccoli and mashed potatoes. Also incredible. Everything tastes homemade(but better). Extremely generous portions too. Friendly service. Can't go wrong. We can't wait to try some other dishes. Highly recommend!”

Customers` Favorites

“My husband and I visited Novino for the first time yesterday, 2/10/2024 for an early dinner. It was a great find. We know it's been there for a while but never tried and we're very glad we did! Great service from Craig. Thank you very much! Great food, good size serving and reasonably priced, good ambiance and clean. Also so happy to finally found our favorite waitress/server from a previous restaurant who works there now (Maura). Highly recommended. Will definitely go back.”

“YUM YUM YUM First of all Larry, the owner is the nicest guy ever. His homemade items are tremendous and never short on taste or flavor. Here is what i cannot live without. Here goes, his homemade bologna, liverwurst, spicy polish loaf, homemade hot dogs and Spanish hot dogs along with his breakfast sausage are items like you never ever had before. Thank GOD he is right in Mahwah , NJ To get these gems of food, I grew up in the 50's and feel I am back in time when quality meant everything. Make sure you stop there and try everyone of these items and you will be a customer forever. None better. Wherever you are, it is well worth the drive to indulge in these amazingly delicious meats. Thanks Larry. Your the best !!!!! p.s Larry actually slices your rye bread by hand and each slice is cut to perfection. He is faster than a machine. AMAZING !!!!!!”

“New to area and found this little gem of a home town deli with secret family kitchen recipes. Wilkes quickly became our favorite spot to stop. Amazing lasagna!Parking: good”

“I love this place. Owners are the best. Super pleasant, love chatting with them. It really something that is missed in customer service today. Old school neighborhood deli, where people remember you. Food is fenominal. Tuna and macaroni salad is amazing. Salads are fresh, breads and bagles are fresh. Prices are excellent.”

Customers` Favorites

“The food here was amazing, I don't know why more people don't know about this place! My meal was vegetarian and my husband's was not and we both had a wonderful timeDietary restrictions: Vegan options as well as vegetarian”

Customers` Favorites

“We love El Azteca! The service is always attentive and friendly. The food is fairly priced, plenty of options, and delicious! We love the tacos, Hec Special, Primo Special, burrito, and quesodilla.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sonny and Tony's was an awesome place to go out and eat with my family. The meals were all great and I felt I got a lot of good bang for my buck. The staff was very friendly and the atmosphere was great for my children. Although it's somewhat of a drive for me, I definitely plan on going back soon to try some of their other menu items. Thank you for the pleasant experience and friendly service!”

Customers` Favorites

“We came on Easter Sunday for lunch as a family of 4 adults and 3 children and we were treated like family. The staff was amazing, they checked in on us multiple times and filled our water every time we needed a refill without having to ask. The bread they serve is warm and tasty and the calamari was perfect.Small negatives: the rib eye steak needed seasoning and the shrimp scampi was nothing special, a little salty… my favorite dish was probably the branzino and the Brussels sprouts.I would return!”

Customers` Favorites

“the saltiness of the ? Sushi is slight more than needed, but a nice cozy place. They get very busy Friday and Saturday b/ w 7pm onwards so definitely call early to reserve a table.”